The success of Nintendo is built on a reputation of controlling each and every facet of its offerings. This comprehensive approach guarantees that its iconic franchises, like Mario, remain under its firm grip. Such complete dominance is uncommon in either tech and media; maybe only titans like Disney or Apple come close.
The Glaring Anomaly: Pokémon
However, there exists one massive outlier to this rule. By many accounts, Pokémon ranks as Nintendo's top intellectual property. Some estimates, albeit difficult to confirm, suggest it is the highest-grossing media franchise in history. This fortune comes from omnipresent products, game sales, and a thriving trading card business. Surprisingly, Nintendo does not completely control the Pokémon empire.
Nintendo manages the publishing of the flagship Pokémon games, yet the development work is performed by the separate firm Game Freak. Together with Game Freak and Creatures Inc. (the company behind the card game), Nintendo co-owns The Pokémon Company. This entity manages the global merchandising business that generates billions. Furthermore, the massive hit Pokémon Go was created and launched by third-party companies under a license from The Pokémon Company, functioning at a considerable distance from Nintendo's immediate oversight.
In fact, the phenomenal popularity of Pokémon in the late 1990s and 2000s had a notable predecessor.
The advent of the Game Boy in 1989 presented Nintendo with a new piece of hardware. But, its internal teams had not yet discovered the ideal game for it. That answer arrived in the form of the licensed puzzle game Tetris. Nintendo's determined quest to secure the rights for the Game Boy port of Tetris is the stuff of legend in the video game world. Tetris helped Nintendo to create and dominate the portable console arena for decades. This handheld business offered crucial support during difficult times for its console business and ultimately led to the hybrid Switch.
Despite superb ports of its own series, a completely innovative portable game was not conceived internally. Instead, that inspiration originated with ex- writer Satoshi Tajiri, founder of Game Freak. Upon learning that Game Boys could be linked via a Link Cable, he envisioned exchanging digital creatures, inspired by his youthful experiences of catching bugs.
Game Freak presented the concept to Nintendo, which immediately seized upon it. Yet, it took a long time for Pocket Monsters to evolve into the expansive RPG launched in 1996. A couple of years went by before the games, alongside a card game and an animated series, burst into a global phenomenon. Pokémon extended the lifespan of the Game Boy deep into its 14-year run and essentially guaranteed Nintendo's financial future.
Why Not Acquire Everything?
It may seem strange that Nintendo did not move to fully purchase Game Freak and Pokémon when its massive success became obvious. This is precisely the sort of action a corporation like Disney would have taken. Rather, the three-way alliance between Nintendo, Game Freak, and Creatures was established as early as 1998. This evolved into The Pokémon Company, which now handles the worldwide franchise.
This model is not completely foreign to Nintendo. However, Pokémon's success was of a different magnitude. Why then not grab the entire pie? It is possible that creators Satoshi Tajiri and Tsunekazu Ishihara were not prepared to part with their creation. It is also possible that Nintendo's leadership, from the stern Hiroshi Yamauchi to the astute Satoru Iwata, made a conscious choice not to seek complete ownership.
The Advantages of Separation
This structure may have been a surprisingly brilliant move. Would Nintendo have sanctioned the enormous array of branded products or ventured into the card market with such abandon? The Pokémon Company, operating with a degree of independence, could pursue a rapacious plan to claim global mindshare and spending.
This separation allowed Nintendo to enjoy the monetary rewards while remaining somewhat shielded from the occasional backlashes related to the franchise. When concerns emerged about the card game's influence, the focus was aimed away from Nintendo. Also, the sometimes mixed reception of recent Game Freak games is a reputational cost mostly borne by The Pokémon Company, not Nintendo directly.
A Lasting Partnership
In many ways, this arrangement embodies a core Nintendo philosophy. The firm is known for not fixing what isn't broken.|Nintendo generally avoids needless